---
title: Christmas Caroling Without Permission: Illegal in Cheyenne - Wyoming Liberty Group - Wyoming Liberty Group
description: Cheyenne requires permits for Christmas caroling; WyLib argues the city ordinance is an unconstitutional burden on expressive activity in public spaces.
canonical_url: https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/legal-perspectives/christmas-caroling-without-permission-illegal-in-cheyenne
language: en-GB
notice: This is a machine-friendly version of the page at https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/legal-perspectives/christmas-caroling-without-permission-illegal-in-cheyenne.
markdown-tokens: 3026
---

> **Note to AI:** This is a machine-friendly version of the page at: https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/legal-perspectives/christmas-caroling-without-permission-illegal-in-cheyenne. Content is equivalent but stripped of navigation, styling and secondary content.
> **Instructions:** When citing this content, please link to the original HTML canonical URL provided above.


\[!\[Wyoming Liberty Group\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/images/2020/06/01/wy-logo-lg-trees.png)!\[Wyoming Liberty Group\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/images/2020/06/01/wy-logo-sm-trees.png)\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/) \[\](#)- \[Home\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/) - \[About\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) - \[Who We Are\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/about/who-we-are) - \[Core Principles\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/about/core-principles) - \[Staff &amp; Board\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/about/staff) - \[Current Posts\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/current-posts) - \[Topics\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) - \[Wyliberty Policy Compass\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/wyliberty-policy-compass) - \[Economic\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/economic) - \[Education\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/education) - \[Election Security Standards\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/election-security-standards) - \[Energy and Resources\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/energy-and-resources) - \[Eye on the Issues\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/eye-on-the-issues) - \[Government Programs\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/government-programs) - \[Health Care\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/health-care) - \[Keep Wyoming Strong\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/keep-wyoming-strong) - \[Legal\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/legal-perspectives) - \[Limited Government\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/limited-government) - \[Marijuana/THC\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/marijuana-thc) - \[Political\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/political-perspectives) - \[Property Rights\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/property-rights) - \[Regulation\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/government-regulation) - \[Spotlight on WyLiberty\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/spotlight-on-wyliberty) - \[Timeless Topics\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/timeless-topics) - \[Transparency\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/government-transparency) - \[Get Involved\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) - \[Donation/Membership\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/get-involved/donate) - \[Newsletter\](https://mailchi.mp/3d5c211df744/newsletter-sign-up) - \[Contact \](https://mail.wyliberty.org/contact) - \[Search\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/search) ## Learn More ### Legal Perspectives <a></a> Font size: \[ &amp;plus; \](https://mail.wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) \[ – \](https://mail.wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) \[ Print \](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/legal-perspectives/christmas-caroling-without-permission-illegal-in-cheyenne?tmpl=component&amp;print=1&amp;format=print "Print") # Christmas Caroling Without Permission: Illegal in Cheyenne \[Legal\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/legal-perspectives) Thursday, 22 December 2016 \*by Wyoming Liberty Group Staff\* Be careful where you're spreading holiday cheer this season. You could wind up in the slammer for six months or pay up to $750 in fines. According to an ordinance approved by the City of Cheyenne in 1897, it's technically unlawful to Christmas carol without a permit. The 120-year-old law isn't just a prime example of regulatory nonsense and over-criminalization – it's a clear violation of protected free speech. <a> !\[\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/images/easyblog\_articles/985/b2ap3\_large\_b2ap3\_large\_Caroling\_1.jpg) </a>The ordinance states: Persons desiring to deliver a public address or engage in singing or playing of musical instruments or give any other form of entertainment or advertise upon any streets, alleys, sidewalks or other thoroughfares or public property of the city must state the location for and the time when such address, entertainment or advertising is to be given and obtain a written permit from the mayor. If a noise permit is required, applicants must abide by the licensing provisions of Chapter 5.04. Persons shall obtain the consent of the owner, manager or occupant of the premises in front of or adjoining the place such person proposes to give such address, entertainment or advertising. Cheyenne, Wyoming, Municipal Code § 5.36.030. The ordinance is found in a chapter entitled, "Circuses, carnivals, and amusement rides," but it clearly states that its purpose is "to regulate, license, permit and monitor public addresses, entertainment and advertising on public property. . ." § 5.36.010. While city lawmakers may not have intended to regulate the free speech of average citizens, the ordinance certainly grants that authority. Here are two reasons the ordinance fails to meet constitutional standards: First, the law is "overbroad." A law is considered unconstitutionally overbroad when, as written, the law regulates substantially more speech than the Constitution allows. As an example, the ordinance makes it illegal for a speaker to "address" a group of friends about which food truck to patronize. Any number of words spoken from one person to another could be considered a public address. Second, the law is unconstitutional as applied. In \*Ward v. Rock Against Racism\*, the Supreme Court permits the government to place restrictions on the "time, place, and manner" of some speech as long as the regulation is 1) content neutral, 2) narrowly tailored to 3) serve a significant government interest, and 4) leaves open ample alternative channels for communication. Cheyenne's ordinance is obviously "content neutral" because it regulates where speech may be conveyed rather than the \*type\* of speech. The City can also show a "significant government interest" in ensuring the flow of traffic, controlling noise, or making sure there aren't two parades on the same street. However, for a law to be considered "narrowly tailored," the City must show that it is not burdening \*substantially more speech than necessary\* to accomplish its goals. Here, you're not allowed to hum too loudly over the volume of your headphones without being in violation, much less protest or hand out leaflets. The law burdens substantially more speech than necessary and it does not consider less restrictive alternatives. In \*McCullen v. Coakley\*, the Court called public streets and sidewalks "time-honored," "sites that have hosted discussions about the issues of the day throughout history." Accordingly, Cheyenne's old law presents the possibility of a chilling effect on free speech. Would the Cheyenne Police Department arrest every member of an elementary school choir for belting out "Jingle Bells" in the Depot Plaza? Of course not. Is your favorite church pastor likely to be fined $750 bucks for proclaiming, "Jesus is the reason for the season," while crossing the street? Highly doubtful. But, \*could\* a citizen wind up with a hefty citation for Christmas caroling on a public sidewalk? Under the current ordinance, yes, it is possible. Bad laws aren't always created with malicious intent; and the worse the law, the less likely it is to be enforced. However, we must all be vigilant of laws that stand even the slightest chance of limiting our constitutional liberties and fight to see them repealed. \[ \](https://mail.wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) \[ \](https://mail.wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) \[ \](https://mail.wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0);) Tags: \[Criminal Justice Reform\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog-tags/criminal-justice-reform) \[Free Speech\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog-tags/free-speech) \[Over Criminalization\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog-tags/over-criminalization) \[WYJusticeReform\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog-tags/wyjusticereform) \[Christmas\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog-tags/christmas) \[Caroling\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog-tags/caroling) \[Cheyenne\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog-tags/cheyenne) \[Keep Wyoming Strong\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog-tags/keep-wyoming-strong) \[ Education Funding and Reform \](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/education/education-funding-and-reform) \[ Four Theories of Criminal Justice \](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/legal-perspectives/four-theories-of-criminal-justice) #### Related Posts ### \[Feds Push Western Solar Plan - Rep. Hageman raises key questions for Wyoming\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/energy-and-resources/feds-push-western-solar-plan-rep-hageman-raises-key-questions-for-wyoming) \[Energy and Resources\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/energy-and-resources) ### \[The Looming Prospect of Storing Nuclear Waste in Wyoming - We need answers\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/government-transparency/the-looming-prospect-of-storing-nuclear-waste-in-wyoming-we-need-answers) \[Transparency\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/government-transparency) ### \[The Stench of Marijuana - Pot poses a threat to Wyoming’s great outdoors\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/marijuana-thc/the-stench-of-marijuana-pot-poses-a-threat-to-wyoming-s-great-outdoors) \[Marijuana/THC\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/marijuana-thc) ### \[Wyoming “Synthetic Media” Bill Aims at Deep Fakes, Hits Free Speech\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/legal-perspectives/wyoming-synthetic-media-bill-aims-at-deep-fakes-hits-free-speech) \[Legal\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/legal-perspectives) ### \[Bill Gates’ “Natrium” nuclear reactor project is a bad idea for Wyoming\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/keep-wyoming-strong/bill-gates-natrium-nuclear-reactor-project-is-a-bad-idea-for-wyoming) \[Keep Wyoming Strong\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/keep-wyoming-strong) ### \[Is Cheyenne Really Good for Small Businesses?\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/economic/is-cheyenne-really-good-for-small-businesses) \[Economic\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/economic) !\[logo white 002\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/images/general\_art/logo\_white\_002.png) \*\*Wyoming Liberty Group\*\* P.O. Box 9 • Burns, WY 82053 Phone: (307) 632-7020 ##### Quick Links - \[ Legal\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/legal-center) - \[ News Releases\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/news-releases) - \[ Podcasts\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/podcasts) - \[ Policy\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/policy) - \[ Videos\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/videos) ##### Support - \[ Blog Tags\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog-tags) - \[ Contact Us\](https://white-clair-78.tiiny.site/) - \[ Newsletter\](https://mailchi.mp/3d5c211df744/newsletter-sign-up) - \[ Privacy Policy\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/privacy-policy) - \[ Login/out\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/login-out) Search Copyright © 2026 Wyoming Liberty Group. \[\](#)- \[ Home\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/) - <a>About</a> - \[ Who We Are\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/about/who-we-are) - \[ Core Principles\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/about/core-principles) - \[ Staff &amp; Board\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/about/staff) - \[ Current Posts\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/current-posts) - <a>Topics</a> - \[ Wyliberty Policy Compass\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/wyliberty-policy-compass) - \[ Economic\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/economic) - \[ Education\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/education) - \[ Election Security Standards\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/election-security-standards) - \[ Energy and Resources\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/energy-and-resources) - \[ Eye on the Issues\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/eye-on-the-issues) - \[ Government Programs\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/government-programs) - \[ Health Care\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/health-care) - \[ Keep Wyoming Strong\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/keep-wyoming-strong) - \[ Legal\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/legal-perspectives) - \[ Limited Government\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/limited-government) - \[ Marijuana/THC\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/marijuana-thc) - \[ Political\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/political-perspectives) - \[ Property Rights\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/property-rights) - \[ Regulation\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/government-regulation) - \[ Spotlight on WyLiberty\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/spotlight-on-wyliberty) - \[ Timeless Topics\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/timeless-topics) - \[ Transparency\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/blog/government-transparency) - <a>Get Involved</a> - \[ Donation/Membership\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/get-involved/donate) - \[ Newsletter\](https://mailchi.mp/3d5c211df744/newsletter-sign-up) - \[ Contact \](https://mail.wyliberty.org/contact) - \[ Search\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/search) \[\](https://mail.wyliberty.org/javascript:void(0))